After I ran my last marathon, in 1998, I told myself that I would never do it again. It was my second one, and while I did marginally better than the first, it was still excruciating. The first fifteen miles were great, but then -- clearly undertrained -- I "bonked" or "hit the wall" and shuffled through the last ten miles. I managed to finish, and even felt good about having done it, but decided that a third helping was unnecessary. Over the years, I would read articles about how unhealthy marathon running is and how it's better to focus on shorter distances and say to myself, that's for sure. Like why would you subject yourself to that kind of torture (more than twice)?I never stopped running, but I spent the next two decades averaging probably fifteen miles each week, a very "recreational" number I think is typical of people who do a few three-mile sessions on the treadmill and maybe a slightly longer run outside on the weekend if the weather's nice. I thought it was enough. Then, almost exactly two years ago, I realized that my knees were aching in a way I had never felt before -- very sharp jabs in the kneecap, characteristic of "runner's knee" -- which made me wonder if I had "overdone it" when I was young and would have to hang up the running shoes for good. It wasn't a happy thought: for most of my life, running was a part of my "identity" that had always been relatively stable and uncontroversial, something I could think about without extremes of pride and anger, or shame and regret, a way to observe the world and its people with a kind of meditative detachment and appreciation. So you can imagine my relief when, after losing a few pounds (via the elliptical), my knees began to feel better. This in turn led me to ramp up the distance, almost as if I owed a tribute of miles to the running gods who had granted me this reprieve, which was why, after I completed a half-marathon in New Orleans last February, I decided I had "no choice" but to sign up for a full marathon, my memories of the prior two notwithstanding. This time, I told myself, I was more disciplined; I knew more about training. I did "intervals" and "hills" and worked on my "core." Having run the NOLA half in 1:26, I knew that breaking three hours in a full wasn't likely, but it wasn't out of the question, either. At the very least, I reasoned, I should be able to run a "BQ," which is how marathoners refer to a time that qualifies for entry in the Boston Marathon, the Holy Grail of runners (who aren't competing in the Olympics or something similar). In a way, running a BQ is easier as you get older; when you're 30, you have to break 3:05; when you're 50 (ahem), you only need to break 3:30. As the race approached, I was filled with anticipation and dread. Starting about a month before the race, I had been checking the weather forecast constantly; historically, the conditions were good for running a marathon at this time of year: not too hot and not too cold. And for a long time, it was supposed to be fifty degrees and overcast. Perfect! As it turned out, however, the weather gods were less interested in my running plans and insisted on scheduling a one-day torrential downpour to begin at 6:00 am with a 100-percent chance of lasting the next eight hours (with the race slated for 8:00 am). Oh well, I thought as I walked through the rain-free town of Rhinebeck the day before the race, at least the houses are pretty and the trees are in bloom. I tried not to worry about the weather or the fact that my right hamstring had been annoyingly tight for the past week or that my sinuses were giving me a migraine for reasons that might have involved allergies, a cold, caffeine deprivation, or stress. I kept reminding myself that, in terms of stress, there was really nothing to worry about; the worst thing would be if I dropped out of the race, with the result that literally not a single person in the world would think the less of me, just as nobody would think more of me if I finished. But that's how it is with distance running, or at least that's how it is with an obsessive like me: you set these goals and feel like Bad Things Will Happen if you don't meet them, even if you know that logic dictates to the contrary. The night before the race, I read most of Haruki Marakami's memoir "What I Talk About When I Talk About Running," which a friend had recently given to me. I found the book very enjoyable, particularly when Murakami was discussing his own obsessive tendencies to run marathons and write novels, which (no duh) I could strongly relate to on both counts. I laughed several times when he discussed running in horrible weather and how he would ask the wind, "what's up with you? why do you have to be so strong?" which is a question I asked many times this winter and spring as I was running up and down the riverbanks of the Hudson. Or how he had made the decision to invert his waking hours, so that he started going to bed at 9:00 pm and waking up at 5:00 am, which is something I started doing. (Granted, he did this in his early thirties, but I could relate!) Or how he described his thoughts while running as constantly changing and not too meaningful, like clouds in a vast sky. Or how he felt like running was a means to give his body a kind of healthy purity to counterbalance the more decadent nature of his writing soul. I woke up several times during the night before the race and stared out the window. The sky was gray and moonless but there was no rain. Maybe the forecast would be wrong and the rain wouldn't start until 11:00 am. As it turned out, the rain began at 6:00 am, just as predicted. I got up, did some stretching, ate a bagel and a banana, and debated whether to wear more than a short-sleeve running shirt to the race, which was about a half mile from the AirBnB where I was staying in town. (Stephen, who had to work, didn't arrive until after the race.) This was a small marathon -- only 100 people or so entered -- so they didn't have the "bag checks" you find at big ones. I decided not to "deal with it," and just wore the shirt. I figured I was going to get soaked anyway; what difference would it make if I got soaked a few minutes early? Rhineback, I should say, is a very charming town; as Stephen commented at breakfast the day after the race, he felt like we had stepped onto the set of "The Gilmore Girls."Outside of our AirBnB, there was a magnificent copper beech. It was at least two hundred years old and, unlike me, completely unfazed by the cold and the rain. Nor did it ever feel the need to run 26.2 miles. Or write novels. Or even blog. We both hated Twitter, however! Here's a picture of the hotel where Lorelai Gilmore got her start in 1766. As I approached the starting line with the other runners in the pelting rain, I considered the passage of time and whether the next three hours would feel like three centuries. Seriously, what was I doing in upstate New York in the middle of a rainstorm about to run 26.2 miles when I could be at home watching the recently released television version of "I Love Dick," surrounded by purring cats? At least I wasn't alone, I thought, which is one of the sad joys of distance running. People "get" each other in this context, which though quite narrow is still wider than most. I don't have any pictures of the race, but the gun went off and we all ran across the starting line, just like runners have done since we were chasing woolly mammoths. Between the weather and some lingering soreness in my legs, I didn't feel that great, but I didn't feel terrible, either. At least it would be over soon, I thought, in the geological sense of the word. The course was two 13.1 laps, almost none of which, it turned out, was flat. The official description was "beautiful rolling hills" that were "challenging." I had known this going into the race -- every race posts "elevation charts" these days -- but had convinced myself that I was prepared after running the hills of Washington Heights. In fact, I wasn't as prepared as I thought, because my training on the riverbank (wind aside) offers long stretches of flat terrain, which did not feature AT ALL in this race. "Hills," I began to ask as the race continued, whether I was running up or down, "what is up with you? why must you be so endlessly rolling?" Still, for the first twenty miles, I ran an average pace of around 6:55, which (I told myself) if I could keep it up would bring me in slightly over three hours. I thought about the many times while training I had easily run six miles at a pace of seven minutes (or faster); it was like not running at all! On this day, however, around the start of mile 20, whether because of the cold, the rain, the lingering soreness, my age, my failure to adequately "hydrate" and/or "fuel" (despite having two "hammer gels"), I hit the proverbial wall and found myself in the "cave of pain." There are many metaphors for this point of a marathon, and all of them are perfect! Anyway, seven-minute miles were now a thing of the past and for the next six miles I was relegated to nine-plus minutes. I arrived at the finish shaking and cold and hungry -- with wooden legs and soggy, heavy shoes -- but most of all relieved. My time was 3:15:08, which was not as fast as I had hoped, but which is a Boston Qualifying time with almost fifteen minutes to spare. (Meaning I should get in; I'll let you know after I register in September.) Next time, I vowed, I would do "better," even though I knew I had already done well enough and literally nothing was "on the line." Unlike the last marathon I ran, when I was filled with a sense of ending, this time I felt a beginning, for which -- at my age, and despite the physical pain -- I could only thank the gods.